Disney Dreamlight Valley: The Keepsake Sea is the paid expansion that sent us underwater on 18 November 2026. We turn into merfolk, explore new sea biomes, and follow the echoes of a lost realm – provided you already own the base game, Disney Dreamlight Valley.
Contents
It shines underwater – until the saves start to stutter
The Keepsake Sea nails the tone we want from a Dreamlight Valley expansion: a lovingly built underwater world, the merfolk transformation, and fresh quests that push the story of the Forgetting a little further. We happily swam through coral and sunken corners, met new companions, and decorated our little settlement under the sea. At the same time, crashes, sticky inputs, and unreliable saves kept yanking us out of that cozy mood. The familiar event pace also made some evenings feel more like a chore than a play session. As a way into the ocean, the expansion is appealing – technically, we would have liked a calmer launch.
How we rate
- 90–100Legendary
- 80–89Very good
- 7270–79Good
- 60–69Okay
- 50–59Mediocre
- < 50Weak
At PlayInsider we rate every game individually and always against the expectations of its genre. We judge the story of an action game or adventure by its narrative quality. In a simulation or management game, on the other hand, what counts is what the genre typically offers. This keeps our ratings fair and comparable within a genre.
The Keepsake Sea: our review in detail
Underwater, The Keepsake Sea looks warmly inviting
Underwater, Dreamlight Valley looks as inviting as we hoped. Coral, light shafts, and the merfolk forms are built with a lot of care, and the Disney characters sit comfortably in that colorful world. The new coast and sea biomes have a look of their own without losing the familiar charm. It is not a graphical leap, but it is a warm, coherent presentation we were happy to linger in.
Still cozy, until the events pick up the pace
The merfolk transformation is the best new idea: suddenly we are swimming through spaces that used to be backdrop, and exploration feels fresh again. New quests, collections, and décor give us plenty to do without tearing up the base game. We were less fond of the Starpath and event pacing. The core is still cozy, but the timed tasks sometimes steal the joy of slowly decorating a new home. Still, when we simply explore the sea, The Keepsake Sea does exactly what an expansion like this should do.
Warmly told, without a big dramatic hook
The journey across the Keepsake Sea to a distant, lost shore gives the expansion its narrative backbone. We follow echoes of the past and pick up new clues about the origin of the Forgetting – a clean continuation of what the base game already set up. New characters and quests give the story its own face without blowing us away. For a cozy life sim, it is a solid, fitting arc rather than a drama we will still be thinking about months later.
More than just a new coat of paint
There is no shortage of content: new regions, story quests, companions, furniture, clothing, and plenty of collecting and decorating to chase. The Deluxe extras with additional companions and cosmetics are noticeable, but the core package still feels complete. If you have lived in the valley for a while, this is clearly more than a new coat of paint. The depth sits in exploration and decorating more than in brand-new systems – and that is exactly where the appeal is for us.
Crashes and shaky saves sour the launch
This is where the expansion cost us the most fun. We ran into repeated crashes and stretches where the game simply froze. On top of that came input issues and saves that did not reliably keep furniture or house changes – including a cloud sync that would not play along. In a decorating sim that hurts, because those little progress beats are the heart of the game. The new content carries the expansion, but the technical side gets in the way too often.
Soft and familiar, without a lasting hook
The underwater world sounds like the soft, warm Dreamlight Valley tone we already know: pleasant, unobtrusive, and in keeping with the cozy mood. The audio supports the atmosphere without pushing itself forward. We did not walk away with a big, memorable musical hook – it does its job well, but it stays more of a companion than a standout.
Going merfolk in The Keepsake Sea
The expansion was developed and published by Gameloft. Official details are on the The Keepsake Sea page and on Steam. We take the merfolk form and move through new underwater biomes built for The Keepsake Sea. There is a pirate-flavored layer along the coast, fresh quests, and a lot of new décor. The Deluxe Edition adds companions such as Flounder and Sebastian plus more cosmetic pieces; we spent most of our time with the core expansion, and it holds up without the extra sparkle.

One thing stays essential: The Keepsake Sea is not a standalone game. You need Disney Dreamlight Valley to play it. The expansion itself is available on a wide set of platforms: PC via Steam and Epic, macOS, PlayStation 4 and 5, Xbox One and Series X|S, Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, and Steam Deck.
Echoes of the past and a lost realm
The story sends us, as merfolk, across the Keepsake Sea to a far-off, lost coast. Along the way we find echoes of the past and new hints that further unpack the myth of the Forgetting – the great emptiness that already shaped the valley in the base game. It is typical Dreamlight Valley: warmly told, with familiar faces and new companions, inviting rather than dark. We liked that the expansion does not just open new spaces, but takes the old story seriously.

When events get in the way of the cozy pace
Between the relaxed decorating and collecting, Starpath and event tasks show up on a tighter clock than the rest of the valley. Some evenings we felt we were ticking off a list instead of falling for a new house under the sea. We know that rhythm from the base game, and it lingers in The Keepsake Sea. If you want to explore the water at your own pace, there is still plenty to do – just not when another event is watching the clock.

















