Sony pulls the plug: PlayStation cancels another live-service shooter

Fairgames canceled: Sony Interactive Entertainment has pulled the plug on Haven Studios' PvP heist shooter after a large-scale playtest apparently fell short of internal targets. According to Sony, there won't be any layoffs.

Fairgames canceled: what we know

PlayStation is walking away from yet another live-service project. As Gematsu reports, citing Bloomberg, Sony Interactive Entertainment has canceled Fairgames, officially stylized as Fairgame$. The multiplayer shooter was in development at Haven Interactive Studios, one of PlayStation's own studios.

Sony first revealed Fairgames at its PlayStation Showcase in May 2023, with the game planned for PlayStation 5 and PC. It never got a release date.

Fairgames canceled: masked thieves with weapons in purple smoke from the Fairgame$ cinematic trailer
A scene from the 2023 reveal trailer. (Image: Haven Studios/Sony Interactive Entertainment)

A playtest with thousands of players missed the mark

According to Gematsu, the decision was laid out in an internal email to staff that Bloomberg reviewed. In it, Sony executives Sean Decker and John Doyle said a recent playtest with thousands of players didn't deliver the results the company had hoped for. Gematsu believes this was the "Project Espresso" playtest it reported on in September.

The email says the test showed strong execution, live ops readiness and community engagement, but that player feedback and retention were mixed and fell short of Sony's goals. Combined with tough market conditions in the PvP shooter space, that led to the call to end development. Here's the full passage:

While the test demonstrated strong operational excellence, live ops readiness, and community engagement, player feedback and retention results were mixed and fell short of the goals we had set. Combined with challenging market conditions in the [player-versus-player] shooter genre, we have made the difficult decision to cease development on the game.

Email from Sean Decker and John Doyle to employees, per Bloomberg via Gematsu

No layoffs at Haven Studios

There is at least some good news for the Montreal team. A Sony Interactive Entertainment spokesperson told Bloomberg that the cancellation won't lead to any job cuts. Instead, Haven will move on to support other studios within PlayStation. Which projects the team will work on next hasn't been revealed.

Fairgames: two characters breaching a fence in a forest at night, scene from the cinematic trailer
Fairgames was all about crews breaking into high-security locations. (Image: Haven Studios/Sony Interactive Entertainment)

What Fairgames was meant to be

Haven Studios was founded in 2021 by Jade Raymond, a veteran producer best known for her work on Assassin's Creed. Sony acquired the Montreal studio in 2022, and Raymond has since left. Fairgames was the team's first original game.

On the PlayStation Blog in 2023, creative director Mathieu Leduc pitched Fairgames as a competitive heist game where you join an underground movement to rob the ultra-rich. You'd break into forbidden locations around the world as a modern-day Robin Hood, a thrill seeker or just someone chasing cool loot. Leduc promised a new kind of PvP game built on "emergent sandbox gameplay."

The Project Espresso playtest description from September lined up with that: a third-person PvPvE game where rival teams race to infiltrate high-security locations, steal valuable cargo and get out before their competitors. Gematsu also noted that trademark filings pointed to a new name, "Break In," though Sony never confirmed it.

Fairgames: masked figure dodging red laser beams in a futuristic corridor
Laser traps and high-tech vaults defined the Fairgame$ trailer. (Image: Haven Studios/Sony Interactive Entertainment)

The bigger picture: Sony's rocky road with live-service games

Fairgames isn't the first live-service project Sony has hit the brakes on. At the same May 2023 showcase, PlayStation also revealed Firewalk Studios' PvP shooter Concord, whose fate we covered in our piece Concord war kein Einzelfall. The reasoning behind the Fairgames cancellation shows just how high the bar has become: even a technically solid test with an engaged community isn't enough if players don't stick around.

For players, it means one fewer heist shooter coming to PS5 and PC. For the industry, it's another sign that publishers are pulling the plug on expensive multiplayer projects earlier. We dug into why in our op-ed Live Service Failures: What the Industry Needs to Learn.